The Pizza

What style is it?

New York Style: Order a big slice from what’s available, or get a massive pizza of your own!

How’s the crust?

I’m looking for crust that holds up with some hefty toppings, but is still enjoyable fresh out of the even as well as the next day.

Sal’s checks all the boxes!

How’s the sauce?

No complaints on the sauce – plenty of it on each slice.

How’s the cheese?

There is a lot of cheese on the pizzas we’ve had!

How are the toppings ?

These slices are LOADED with toppings, and they are fresh + flavorful as well.

Overall Eating Experience

Quality of Ingredients

Everything looks and tastes excellent!

Taste

No complaints here — would recommend!

Mouth Feel

Sal’s locks down a 9/10 for mouth feel, based on the pizzas I’ve tried.

Post-Meal Regrets — when dinner bites back

None here to report!

Thoughts from a lactose-intolerant

Specific pizzas we’ve tried

Meat Lover’s

Sal’s Special

Veggie

Bruschette Pizza

The PIC Verdict:

4 — Definitely will visit again in the future

Much like Arnold, we’ll be back!

The In-Person Experience — what to expect

First Thought

“There are a LOT of bars on the windows!”

Atmosphere

Sit where you’d like — we sat close to the kitchen by choice, and it got to be a little toasty.

People + Service

The staff was wonderful, thoughtful, and patient with my many questions!

Cost

Convenience Factor

The Website

Menu Access

Ease of Ordering

Best to Call, Order Online, or Order in Person?

Website Usability

Mobile

Desktop

BONUS ITEMS:

Appetizers

The wings were pretty nice! I got the golden sauce. There was some skin left on the wings — not sure if that just depends on the batch they get or if it’s the intention, but it meant I didn’t have to share with my wife!